A 1099 discharge of debt is not a release from liability under the contractual obligation of the note and mortgage. It serves as a notice to the IRS that they do not believe they will recover the debt and for tax purposes the debt is forgiven; however, they could still file suit to collect the debt and the mortgage still serves as a lien on the collateral property if they did so, the 1099 would be reversed. In your case it would still have to be a short sale. The second loan was not discharged as you believe. Even a discharge under bankruptcy would only protect you from personal liability and still require a short sale, unless the lien was also removed from the property as part of the process.
Answered on Jul 01st, 2013 at 12:28 PM