Will I go to jail for creating a fake account on a psychic website?

I went to a psychic site to see if things would get better for me because times are tough, but I was embarrassed to use my full name so I used my first name and my middle name for one, but I used my street address and the other personal info and then they suspended my account. Then after, I made another account keeping my personal info the same, but I tried putting my real first and last name down. However, my computer froze, and I did this a couple times. So a couple days ago, they called me after the most recent account was suspended and told me that I owed them money because they reimbursed me on the cards that I used since they were in someone else's name, but those cards were in my actual name and I tried telling them. So they said if I can't pay the full amount they will have a collection agency contact me, but when I asked them how much I owe, they didn't know and told me to call back when the billing department is available.