Church employee broke one of my vases but Church claims they aren''t responsible unless permission to leave the vases was given. What to do?
Asked on Jul 23rd, 2012 on Business Law - Arkansas
More details to this question:
I am a floral vendor that supplied flower arrangements for a wedding client last October. After the wedding on Saturday, the altar arrangements were left at the church for Sunday mass. Later in the week, a church employee broke one of my vases while cleaning it.
The Catholic church Diocese is claiming client liability unless permission was given to the client from the Pastor to leave the vases after the wedding. The client''s mother insists that the pastor gave permission on the night of the wedding.
I know the individual church (and probably the entire Catholic church) provides a Hold Harmless agreement to the clients upon renting the facility. However I''m not sure how this would apply since several members of the Diocese claim that liability is dependent on whether or not permission to leave the vases was granted.
It seems like a he said-she said fiasco and I''m not sure how to approach it from here. It''s coming on the 1-year anniversary of this nightmare and I''m still getting nowhere on
I think the problem is even worse for you than you apparently think. In the absence of some kind of notice to the church that the vase was yours and that it needed to be cared for, the church arguably owed you no duty of care. Indeed, since the vase was not removed on a timely basis following the expiration of the rental, the church may have been privileged to asssume that it was abandoned. Move on.
Consumers can use this platform to pose legal questions to real lawyers and receive free insights.
Participating legal professionals get the opportunity to speak directly with people who may need their services, as well as enhance their standing in the Lawyers.com community.