It depends. The answer is too complex and involved to reply in writing. You should expect a private attorney to spend more time with you, to be easier to contact and to call you back. You may have a great deal of trouble getting in touch with your Deputy Public Defender, at least until you have set a trial date and he or she needs to confer with you for trial preparation. On the other hand, some private attorneys are just hacks who send you advertising or who practice many areas of law. If the Attorney practices more than a couple of areas, and particularly if Criminal Law is not his or her primary area, or co-primary area, run, don't walk. You will just be giving your money to someone who will only tell you whatever the D.A. is offering. They either will not know how, or won't want to bother, to try to improve the deal, if they even really know what to do with a DUI, which is a highly involved area of law. With the Public Defender's Office,
you are generally, but not always, going to get a younger, less-experienced attorney on a misdemeanor. I have seen fantastic work at trial by some Deputy P.D.'s. Just as with private Attorneys, Deputy Public Defenders vary widely in talent, experience, ability, intelligence, motivation and commitment.
Answered on Jan 02nd, 2011 at 1:58 PM