I am not sure that I understand your question, but I think I know what you are trying to ask. I will, therefore, attempt to answer what I 'believe' you are asking. It appears that you are confusing an act about pre-trial detention - the Federal Pretrial Services Act of 1982 (FPSA) which is a purely legal matter - with a general principle of the law - the presumption of innocence which is a purely factual matter. The Federal Pretrial Services Act (FPSA) was created to reduce the number of people re-arrested after the initial arrest, reduce the number of people who fail to appear, and to reduce the number of people on pre-trial detention (it has failed at the last; it appears to have increased the number of people on pre-trial detention). To accomplish these goals, the FPSA aims to provide the magistrates with reports that have no regard as to the evidence associated with a defendant's guilt. This decision is purely legal. On its own, it is supposed to have no impact on the case. Rather, it is supposed to be used to determine the following factors to determine if any bond is necessary: 1. Financial Resources of Accused 2. Family Ties 3. Employment or Education 4. Length of Residence in Community 5. Record of Convictions (VCIN & Local) 6. Record of Court Appearances, Flight to Avoid Prosecution, Failures to Appear 7. Substance Abuse Information 8. Any Other Information Which Court Considers Relevant According to the act, there should not be any discussion of the weight of evidence and the circumstances of instant offense (or offenses). A jury would decide these issues. On its face, therefore, the act has nothing to do with guilt or innocence but, rather, has everything to do with the likelihood that a defendant will reappear or re-offend. Of course, this ignores that defendants held on bond are far more likely to accept guilty pleas. When I was in law school, I worked for a criminal defense attorney who stated the obvious - the most important hearing in any case is the bail hearing because it sets the tone for the entire case.
Answered on Aug 21st, 2012 at 1:31 PM