Can a defendant sign a plea agreement and then withdraw the plea before sentencing?

Question

If you sign a plea agreement and the court accepts it but it has not yet been sentenced, can a defendent withdraw from the plea on or before sentencing?

Leonard A. Kaanta · Answer

Only by motion and permission from the judge.

Jason Savela · Answer

Under some circumstances but you need a good reason and it must be prior to sentencing.

Gregory Crain · Answer

Yes.

Edward Blum · Answer

Yes.

Gary Russell · Answer

Yes.

Michael Edwards · Answer

The answer to your question is: maybe.  If you file a motion to withdraw your guilty plea before you are sentenced, the judge will then hold a hearing on your motion.  You have the burden of convincing the judge that your guilty plea was not knowingly and voluntarily entered.  If you can do that, the judge will let you withdraw your plea.  If you cannot prove that, then the judge will not let you withdraw your plea.  You might want to consult with a good criminal defense attorney, to find out whether or not the facts of your case will likely give you the results you seek.  Good luck!

Francis Cowhig · Answer

Sometimes, depending on the circumstances and why you wish to withdraw from the agreement.  This is something that you should be discussing with your attorney.

Dennis Roberts · Answer

very hard to do and you need a really great reason, but ask your attorney as he  knows that judge and that county.

Jared Altman · Answer

The answer is yes, if the judge lets you.

Jared Winter · Answer

Yes, but there has to be a good reason.  The court will not allow someone to withdraw their plea just because they've changed their mind.  You should contact a criminal defense lawyer in your area for consultation.

Mark Smith · Answer

In federal court once the plea agreement is accepted by the court you   cannot withdraw the agreement. But that will not preclude you from filing a   motion to withdraw the plea.

Timothy Klisz · Answer

Yes, it's up to the judge to allow it.

Mark R. Thiessen · Answer

You can, but the court is going to be furious.  So better have a good reason and prepare your lawyer to get his ass chewed out.

Gregory Casale · Answer

First off, the rules are different in Superior Court than they are in District Court. It sounds as if you are in Superior Court and if that is the case, the answer is no. If you are in district court, the sentence is part of the defendant capped plea and if the sentence is not defined, the judge should not have accepted a plea.

Stephen Richards · Answer

Yes, but the standard is very high. You need a good reason for withdrawing.

Larry Dunn · Answer

A judge has the discretion to allow a person to withdraw a guilty plea   prior to sentencing but it is not mandatory. A judge will weigh a number of   factors in deciding whether to allow the withdrawal of a plea.

If a  pre-sentence  report has been completed and a recommended sentence is known, it may be  more  difficult to withdraw a plea. The sooner the request is made, the  more likely it  will be allowed. If a person simply has 'buyer's remorse' a  judge is less likely  to allow withdrawal of a plea versus a finding that the  attorney failed to fully  advise of the consequences of a plea. The fact that  a judge accepted the plea  after an extensive plea canvass makes it less  likely that a plea can be  withdrawn.

Terry Nelson · Answer

Sure, but don't expect to be offered a better, or even ANY new plea bargain. You WILL have to go to trial on the charges if you dishonor your agreement.

Dennis P. Mikko · Answer

A request can be made of the court to withdraw the plea.  There would have to be a reason for the withdrawal.  It would be up to the discretion of the court as to whether the plea is withdrawn.

James Edward Smith · Answer

If you have good cause the Judge may allow that.

Steven Alpers · Answer

It is unlikely. The court normally asks you if you understand that you will not be able to withdraw your plea agreement. Unless your attorney failed to act competently there is not a reason a court will allow you to withdraw your plea. Also, if the DA agrees they may want to go for more punishment.

Joseph Dane · Answer

Yes, if the court grants their motion to withdraw their plea.

Michael Clinton · Answer

Generally no, but there are exceptions.

Timothy Byrne · Answer

Some judges will permit this but they do not have to.

Herschel Bullen · Answer

The only time you can withdraw the plea in either State or Federal Court is before sentencing.  State statute provides:  (2)(a) A plea of guilty or no contest may be withdrawn only upon leave of the court and a showing that it was not knowingly and voluntarily made. (b) A request to withdraw a plea of guilty or no contest, except for a plea held in abeyance, shall be made by motion before sentence is announced. Sentence may not be announced unless the motion is denied. For a plea held in abeyance, a motion to withdraw the plea shall be made within 30 days of pleading guilty or no contest. Utah Code Ann. ? 77-13-6  Federal Rule provides:  (d) Withdrawing a Guilty or Nolo Contendere Plea. A defendant may withdraw a plea of guilty or nolo contendere: (1) before the court accepts the plea, for any reason or no reason; or(2) after the court accepts the plea, but before it imposes sentence if: (A) the court rejects a plea agreement under Rule 11(c)(5); or(B) the defendant can show a fair and just reason for requesting the withdrawal. Fed. R. Crim. P. 11

Clayton Lockhart · Answer

The general rule is that you can voluntarily withdraw your consent to a plea agreement at any time "prior" to the court's acceptance of the plea. Once the judge announces that your plea has been accepted, then you will have to make a motion to ask the court to allow you to withdraw your plea. Then it will be up to the judge to grant or deny your motion. If he grants the motion, then you can withdraw your plea, if he denies the motion then you have to appeal his decision.

Michael J. Breczinski · Answer

They can for good cause and with the court's permission. The court has to grant permission to withdraw the plea.

Harley Gutin · Answer

Once the plea is accepted you would have to file a Motion to Withdraw the plea.  In said motion you would have to state sufficient grounds to convince the judge that the plea was not knowingly and, or voluntarily entered into.

John Toivonen · Answer

It depends on the circumstances. If the Defendant has a plea agreement and the judge intends to sentence the Defendant to more time than stated in the agreement, he can withdraw his plea. 

In other situations it depends on the reason for withdrawing the plea. If the Defendant can establish that he was threatened into taking the plea, or defrauded, the court should rule that he can withdraw his plea.

Steven D. Dunnings · Answer

You have to have a reason other than you changed your mind.

Robert De Groot · Answer

Consult with an attorney about the reasons why the plea should be withdrawn. It can be withdrawn but only upon certain grounds.

Stephen Freeborn · Answer

Yes.  The sentencing judge will generally allow that.

Ronnie Vargas · Answer

The defendant or the defendant's attorney would need to file a motion to withdraw the guilty plea and the Court would need to hear said motion. Here's a case which addresses the issue of withdrawing guilty pleas. "A hearing on a motion to withdraw a guilty plea is to be liberally granted if the motion is made prior to sentencing; it is discretionary if made thereafter and need not be granted if the record refutes the allegations. The defendant must raise a substantial issue of fact."

Eric Sterkenburg · Answer

If you signed a plea agreement and the court accepts that plea agreement, then you cannot withdraw the plea. When the court accepts your plea you agreed that you were making the plea voluntary and without duress. Additionally the court asks if you give up certain rights. One of the rights is any post-conviction processes. This includes withdrawing and changing your plea. You may however tell your attorney that you changed your mind if the plea has not been accepted by the court.

Nathaniel Shafer · Answer

In Utah, you have 30 days to withdraw from a plea agreement, if you have not been sentenced.

Mark Arneson · Answer

You would have to file a Motion to Withdraw Plea.  Under Rule 15.05 of the Minnesota Rules of Criminal Procedure:  "In its discretion the court may allow the defendant to withdraw a plea at any time before sentence if it is fair and just to do so, giving due consideration to the reasons advanced by the defendant in support of the motion and any prejudice the granting of the motion would cause the prosecution by reason of actions taken in reliance upon the defendant's plea."  Basically, you must provide the court with a good reason why your plea should be withdrawn.

Michael Morgan · Answer

There are certain grounds to withdraw a plea but if this is simply a case of buyer's remorse then that alone is not sufficient grounds to withdraw a guilty plea. Email transmissions to clients of this office presumably contain confidential and privileged material for the sole use of the intended recipient. The use, distribution, transmittal or re-transmittal by any unintended recipient of any communication is prohibited without our express approval in writing or by email.

Gary Moore · Answer

He can TRY. The problem is that a defendant is usually sworn under oath and is required to give a recitation of facts that the judge relies upon in permitting the guilty plea.

Michael Dungan · Answer

You have the right to ask to withdraw your plea, but the judge has the discretion to say yes or no.

Arthur Aiken · Answer

In South Carolina, a defendant can withdraw a plea accepted by the Court only under certain circumstances. The applicable rules are highly technical, so you will definitely need to hire a lawyer to help you with this.

Jason Richards · Answer

Yes. a plea of guilty or no contest may be withdrawn only upon leave of the court and a showing that it was not knowingly and voluntarily made.  A request to withdraw a plea of guilty or no contest, except for a plea held in abeyance, shall be made by motion before sentence is announced.  See Utah Code Ann. 77-13-6

Russell Pietryga · Answer

In theory, yes.  But, you are going to have to file a motion to withdraw the plea and explain why your plea was not freely and voluntarily made.  Hope this helps.

Bernard Jones · Answer

It depends on why it is being withdrawn. More information is needed.

John Patrick Yetter · Answer

If you have entered a plea which was accepted by a court generally you have been sentenced, even if the sentence (say, a jail sentence)  isn't enforced until later.  Under Illinois law you would have 30 days to file a motion to withdraw your plea.

Jennifer Leigh Gottschalk · Answer

It can be difficult to withdraw the plea before sentencing.  Once you have given a factual basis and the court has accepted it, it is difficult for a court to allow you to retract or rescind it, because you are in essence telling the court not to have believed what you said during the plea hearing, that you lied.

Gregory Graf · Answer

Yes you can withdraw from the agreement before sentencing.

Joseph Redding · Answer

You can file a motion to do so.  The court does not have to allow it.

Jeff Yeh · Answer

Possible, but it is up to the Judge, who can deny it. Your best bet is to have a good lawyer present the motion to withdraw the plea. There are statutory guidelines, and if your lawyer doesn't know what he/she is doing you will probably be denied.

Bruce Arthur Plesser · Answer

With good cause

Ernest Lee · Answer

Friend:                  It is possible but difficult to withdraw a plea agreement. You must convince the court that the original plea was made under duress or it was not knowingly and intelligently done. That is, not that it was a smart thing to do, but that you didn't know or understand what you were doing and or it was done without much rational thought.

Austin Hirschhorn · Answer

Michigan Court Rule 6.310 (A) permits the defendant to withdraw any plea until the court accepts it on the record.  6.310 (B) permits withdrawal after acceptance but before sentence on the defendant's motion or with the defendants consent, only in the interest of justice, and may not be withdrawn if withdrawal of the plea would substantially prejudice the prosecutor because of reliance on the plea.  If there is a sentence agreement or recommendation and the court is not going to follow it, the court must inform the defendant of what the sentence will be and the defendant then has the choice of accepting the court intends to impose or withdraw the plea and go to trial.  There are other situations discussed in the rule that you should probably review with the attorney that is representing you before you make your decision.

Find a Lawyer

Ask a Lawyer

Read Legal Articles

Ask a Lawyer

Read Legal Articles

Can a defendant sign a plea agreement and then withdraw the plea before sentencing?

50 ANSWERS

Find Local Criminal Law Lawyers

Helpful Resources

Ask a Lawyer