1. Yes. He can sue you. Whether he wins is another story. The cost of a PS4 controller is less than $50. The filing fees for small claims can range from $130-$300, and that's just to file the action. If he wanted to bring a lawyer on he would spend more on costs and fees than he would if he went and purchased a new PS4 controller, a new PS4 system, all new games, and a new TV.
2. Yes. He could still sue you, but his case would be much weaker as he does not have any damages.
Answered on Aug 11th, 2016 at 7:35 PM