What states have decided that court ordered AA is a violation of the Constitution?

I have never heard of any States deciding AA is unconstitutional. They all order some sort of alcohol treatment.

Are you asking me to do your research for you? I think that is the whole idea, that YOU do the research. Good luck.

AA is based upon a religious foundation. Because of this, most courts, rather than making AA part of the treatment program, simply require that the person attend "self help" group sessions. This may or may not be AA. I suspect that most states handle treatment in this fashion.

I have no idea, and I'm not the one doing what will be time consuming research. Use your key word search terms and start looking on the web, state by state, or use your school's subscription to professional legal research sites, or go to local law schools and use theirs. No one is going to do your research for you, and asking us for the answers is NOT you researching. Even if we gave you some answers, can you trust them? It would be an April Fool joke to mislead you and have you crash and burn.

Alabama, Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Oregon, Michigan, Colorado, Florida, Iowa, Ohio, Illinois, New Mexico, Maine, South Carolina, Virginia, Wyoming, Hawaii, Kansas and Texas have deemed it unconstitutional. States that have held it CONSTITUTIONAL are North and South Dakota, Louisiana, Delaware, Maryland, New York, Vermont, Utah, Nevada, Arizona, Idaho, and Alaska. The rest of the state's highest courts have not passed on the issue, but currently Georgia and North Carolina's highest courts have heard oral arguments on the issue and should each render a decision in the near future. You can obtain copies of the legal briefs here: http://www.georgiacourts.org/ and here: http://www.nccourts.org/, or by calling (919) 831-5700 (NC) or 404-656-5171 (GA). You can check these links for more info: http://legallad.quickanddirtytips.com/does-mandatory-alcoholics-anonymou s-violate-constitution.aspx, http://ffrf.org/faq/state-church/court-ordered-participation-in-a.a/, and http://nccriminallaw.sog.unc.edu/?p=784. I'm glad I could help - best of luck!

How would any attorney know this? We are only licensed in one state and beyond that, this is your assignment for you to research, not to ask on a legal question and answer site.