I can only comment on your case as far as the information you have provided and according to Utah law; as such, what I share here is cannot be used as legal advice for your particular situation but only legal information strictly limited to the facts you have shared. All of the facts that you relate in your detail are relevant for a judge to consider and allowing your son to change his name. If the biological father will not consent to the name change, then you must simply petition the court and see what a judge will do. In these cases, normally I find that the stepfather who has been the "real father" is seeking to adopt the child by involuntarily terminating the biological father's parental rights, which would also terminate the black biological father's duty to pay child support. The "bribe" you mention is not legal in Utah because the right to support is the child's right and not the custodial parent's right to turn down. All that being said, the biological father has his parental rights, which are constitutional and which may be a good enough reason for a judge not to allow your son to change his last name.
Answered on Jan 29th, 2013 at 2:18 PM