It sounds as if she is being charged with Contempt of Court, as such she could face jail time. If, after a court hearing, you have the possibility of being incarcerated AND you don't have the funds to hire your own attorney, you may be appointed an attorney to represent you. Because your brother is not facing any jail sentence (he's not being charged with anything), he does not qualify for a public defender. Your brother does not have to hire an attorney for this, but because of the consequences, contempt must follow certain rules of court very carefully, therefore, an attorney would be very helpful to him. In California, your brother's ex is the one with the burden to prove that she was unable to pay support, after your brother is able to show that there was a valid court order, that she was aware of the order (she was served or she was present in court when the order was made), and that she did not pay as ordered. These three things are quite easy to prove. Then the burden shifts to her to prove she was literally unable to pay and that she didn't put other debts above the obligation to support her children. Your brother will probably want to subpoena her bank records during the months in question, the court's self help center can help him with that.
Answered on Apr 11th, 2014 at 5:58 PM