my husband came on D1 visa and we field for this paper and was denial and was approve for a I130 it has been over nine years and haven't here as yet

A person who entered the United States on a crew member visa cannot adjust status unless grandfathered under INA 245(i). This person can only pursue an immigrant visa through consular processing. Your spouse may qualify for a provisional waiver but there is not enough information to assess the matter fully. I would encourage you to meet with an experienced immigration attorney.