Trademark rights are "earned" through use in a particular location over time. The longer a trademark is used, the stronger it is. The prior restaurant you mention in your question has a strong mark since you said it has been established under its trademark for many years. The owner of the existing restaurant can sue you for trademark infringement if your restaurant name is likely to cause confusion in the minds of the public. If your proposed restaurant name makes the ordinary consumer think that the two restaurants are related, then trademark infringement exists and the current restaurant owner can stop you from using this similar name.
An example showing restaurant names that could be likely to be confused is "McCormick and Schmick's" (an existing seafood and grill restaurant) when compared to "McCormick and Mick's" or "McCormac and Mack's." In your example, "Maple Ridge Restaurant" would definitely be likely to cause confusion with 'Maple Restaurant' if the two restaurants are located in the same geographic area and draw from the same customer base.
Answered on Nov 11th, 2011 at 2:53 PM