Appellate Practice Attorney serving New York, NY
With all due respect to your police friend, I think he/she is wrong. It's a crime to withhold osmeone's mail. Google "is it a crime to withhold someone's mail" and you'll see. The fact that you have a claim against that person for money you cliam she owes you (all it is is a claim until and unless you win a lawuit and get a judgment, but you still woulnd' thave the right to withhold her mail) doesn't change this. You have no contract with this person in which she agrees to let you withhold her mail until she pays you back, nor is there any statute which allows you to withhold mail until your claim is satisfied. Give her her mail and sue her in small claims court.
Answered on Apr 27th, 2020 at 1:25 PM