What monetary value along with apologies can I get on oral defamation/slander?

Question

Robbery took place at mom and pop’s store early hours in the morning. I was accused of being accessory of the crime.   My photo was posted on the store window and family, friends have seen it.  The owner has been avoiding me and now wants to settle.

Melvin Franke · Answer

What are your economic damages?

Stephen Freeborn · Answer

It depends upon how you have been damaged.   I would need to know more about the facts of the case.

William C. Gosnell · Answer

Lost income lost business and lost money is your measure of damages. Since your family does not believe you are guilty.

David Stoddard · Answer

If you were slandered, you would be entitled to whatever damages you could prove.  If it did not cause you to lose a job, and if your family and friends who saw it didn't think less of you, your damages aren't much.  If that is the case, get what you can.

Steven Alpers · Answer

That is not a question I can answer without more information.  Defamation damages depend on how much your reputation in the community was damaged.  If no one believed you were the robber nominal damages.  If you lost friends and/or business the damages would go up.

James Osak · Answer

Get several hundred dollars PLUS have them POST an APOLOGY for 90 days on their FRONT DOOR (or window). MOVE ON. You're not going to get much from a "mom and pop" store.

Mark Smith · Answer

What ever you think is fair.

Britany Engelman · Answer

This may be a case for libel considering it was in writing and was published. You may be entitled to money damages. An "apology" is not a typical remedy in a civil case, but can possibly negotiated by your attorney.

Ronald A. Steinberg · Answer

You have to show a loss of standing in the community.

Paul Whitfield · Answer

You did not say you were innocent. Assuming you are, an accusation of crime is actionable as llibel (in writing) you must prove some actual damage (jobloss for example) Otherwise you might wind up with nominal damages ($!) all up the the jury. You wont likely get big bucks just for hurt feelings. Show some real loss if there is any.

Jeffrey Pollock · Answer

One would need way more info to assess this.  Has your income been   impaired by this?  How deep is the owner's pockets, etc.

Dennis P. Mikko · Answer

What was the damage to your reputation?  Have you lost employment, friends, etc. as a result?  After answering these questions, you may have a clearer picture of your damages.  There is no mathematical formula to determine damages.  You will have to decide to what extent you have been damaged.

Michael Chastaine · Answer

That depends on a lot of factors. If your serious about pursuing this you should get an attorney.

Gregory Crain · Answer

Ask for a reasonable amount.

Stephen Lombardi · Answer

"Settle"? Meaning you've sued the people who slandered you? If so   you need to ask your lawyer for that advice since they are the one's who  know  the facts of your case. As for a lawyer on this forum being able to value  your  case, we can't do it without knowing more. And why would you think a  lawyer  should just give you their opinion for nothing about the value of a  case? What  do you do for a living? If you were a plumber would it be  alright for me to ask  you to fix my sink without getting paid? If not, then why  is alright to ask  lawyers to? Hire a lawyer and then follow their advice.

Michael Heilmann · Answer

Cases are very difficult to pursue because you will to be unable to show damages.  Were you fired from your job? Did you lose money anywhere? You are all considerations when you are looking at damages.

Andrew Velonis · Answer

It's only slander if they knew that it was untrue. From what you describe, it sounds like a mistake. How about if he puts a poster of you up on the store window with a banner "Customer of the Year" and keeps it there twice as long as the original picture, plus a case of beer.

William Spern · Answer

Hard to say how it affects you given the minimal facts. Why not do a Google search and see if any other cases similar to your that settled. They may give you an idea of what the case might be worth.

Bernard Huff · Answer

You should consult with a plaintiff's lawyer who handles defamation cases for  specific legal advice, including an evaluation and settlement of your  case/claim.

Michael Palumbo · Answer

You can recover your economic damages. How much money did you lose due to his slander. If you lost nothing that is what you are entitled to - 0.

Keven A. McKenna · Answer

If a jury thinks it is a defamation, it can award compensatory and punitiive damages. Do not get your hopes up.

Thomas Bulman · Answer

That would be $1,000.

Find a Lawyer

Ask a Lawyer

Read Legal Articles

Ask a Lawyer

Read Legal Articles

What monetary value along with apologies can I get on oral defamation/slander?

22 ANSWERS

Find Local Litigation Lawyers

Helpful Resources

Ask a Lawyer