The insurance company is correct. In Maryland (and it is my understanding that the law is the same in all states) the law only requires that the insurance company pay you the value of your vehicle and not what you owe the bank on the loan. You have the right to dispute the value of the vehicle if you can come up with proof that the vehicle is worth more money that what the insurance company claims is the value of the vehicle. Proof of the value of the vehicle can come from different sources (e.g. a used car dealership, the value of a similar vehicle listed in the newspaper or on the internet). Good luck with this matter.
Answered on Jul 17th, 2013 at 8:37 PM