Negligence, yes, damages questionable. Here's why: children falling asleep on a bus is a known problem among school bus drivers. That is why (among other reasons) drivers are required to check their bus when turning it back to the garage. The driver either didn't do the required check, or did an inadequate job. So there's negligence. Therefore, the bus company is liable. But liable for what? There was no physical injury. Inconvenience and anxiety, but nothing beyond that. All cases are evaluated as against what a jury might award. Without a showing of any actual injury, a jury is likely to award only nominal damages. It would be worth pursuing management about the improper actions of it's driver, though. If they don't give you a satisfactory response (and my bet is that they won't) then complain to the school board: If they did this to your son, how many times has it happened to other children? Will anybody give you an honest answer to that question? If they claim that they don't keep track of that information, they should. What other problems are they ignoring? If they refuse to take steps to correct this situation, then what else is likely to go wrong in the future? Would it be better for the school to not renew the contract with the bus company and instead hire its own drivers?
Answered on Oct 28th, 2013 at 6:03 PM