They are trying to get a break to which they are not entitled. Nonetheless, you should submit the bills to your health insurance for the following reasons: 1) You never know for certain that you will recover anything from the at fault driver. In your case, it appears that insurance company is admitting liability and you will at least recover your bills. However, you may not be able to settle the case and might have to take it to trial. Juries have been known to give zero verdicts even in cases of admitted liability, 2) You might be unable to settle the case and have to go to trial, which could take years. Meanwhile, the medical bills go into collection. 3) Most importantly, your health insurance usually get a discount on the medical bill. You will pay less in medical bills if you let the health insurance pay for it. The at fault driver is liable for the entire cost your medical bills that were incurred for injuries caused by the accident (insurance companies often argue that they did not cause all of the problems for which you incurred bills). They do not get any credit for any third party sources who will pay your bills, such as health insurance, Medicare, Medicaid, or personal injury protection through your auto insurance. This is based on a legal doctrine called the collateral source rule. You will have to reimburse your health insurer from any settlement you receive (usually, depending on how your policy is worded), and the at fault driver's insurance company may have to reimburse the health insurer directly before paying you if the health insurer puts them on notice of its subjugation rights. However, what the at fault driver pays for medical bills is usually higher than what has to be paid to the health insurer because of the discount I mentioned above.
Answered on Oct 23rd, 2012 at 7:30 AM