How can I have local newspaper remove the record of my arrest on their website?

In 2010, I was arrested, and subsequently, a record of my arrest appeared in the local newspaper. In 2012, I contacted the newspaper, asking for their public record removal policy, when the publisher informed me that arrest notifications typically only remain in the paper's online version for two weeks. Based on this information, I kindly asked that my arrest record be removed. However, the publisher/owner of this small town paper has refused to delete the record, even after the conviction has been expunged. I am simply trying to clean up my online image, and this public record of my arrest has harmed me beyond belief. I fully understand the constitutional rights of the press, but this wantonly abusive behavior goes beyond the bounds of privilege and is unconscionable and malicious, particularly since other profiles which appeared in 2010 have been removed automatically. And, the publisher admitted that profiles should not remain longer than two weeks. It's interesting to know what the newspaper owner's motivation is for keeping my arrest record online. What type of redress do I have under state and/or federal law?