I Paid for services that wasn't rendered, Seeking Legal representation for this matter

We (Geico and I) paid Auto Paint And Body Shop $5,944.42 for my 2019 Dodge to be repaired at their facility. We (Geico and I) acknowledge the repairs were not done. Shop had car for over a month. Shop called and said car was repaired and ready for pick up. I took pictures and videos addressed issues with shop manager/owner, called Geico advised them of the same, paid the deductible and collected my car. Geico return to my home did an after service assessment, acknowledged no repairs were done, took additional pictures, and documented findings. We have been scammed out of $5,944.42 for services not rendered