You might be able to get the first insurance company to pay for the whole bill, but you would probably have better luck getting the insurance companies to split the bill. It is important to realize the insurance companies may have a valid argument that this was an unavoidable accident that was not the responsibility of either of their insureds, in which case you will recover nothing. I recommend taking what settlement you can get.
Answered on Feb 21st, 2012 at 4:56 PM