You can not sue him. You were at fault in hitting his vehicle. You should not have been driving so closely behind him so as to hit his vehicle, even if he stopped suddenly. You may have been going slowly, but not only 1 mph. Your insurance company would not have paid for a bumper replacement unless they felt there was sufficient damage as to require it. Even at a very slow impact speed it is possible to suffer some injuries. So it would be very difficult to prove that he has made a false claim. I doubt any attorney would be willing to take your case. If he was not injured, your insurance company will take that position. As a practical matter, this is just one of the the various insults people have to face in life that they can not really do anything about.
Answered on Oct 13th, 2014 at 3:25 PM