Since the car is in your name, only, you should absolutely report it as stolen. I don’t know why you were told you could not do that. He has no right to the car which is in your name.
However, as a practical matter, even if it is reported as stolen, there is no way to assure it will be retrieved. You have rights, civilly, to sue him for conversion which is the civil version of theft. Of course, you would only be able to obtain a judgment for the value of the car which you would then have to attempt to collect.
Regrettably, your only viable option is to find another vehicle. Notify your insurance company that it was stolen and take whatever action they advise you.
I trust this answers your questions, and, if you live in the Delaware Valley, feel free to call or email on a free initial basis.
Best Regards,
Matthew R. Nahrgang, Esquire
35 Evansburg Road, Ste 400
Collegeville, PA 19426
(610) 489-3041 o
(610) 489-3042 fax
nahrganglaw.com
Answered on Feb 24th, 2022 at 10:23 AM