In most standard leases you are allowed to charge a fee for damages beyond "normal wear and tear." Heavy smoking could definitely be construed as being beyond normal usage of the property, so you should be allowed to charge for your actual cleaning costs. Make sure you get a receipt from your cleaning service and/or from whomever you purchase the new carpeting to back up whatever charges you pass on to the tenant. You may give the tenant the opportunity to find a less expensive (but still acceptable) alternative, in case you are worried about collecting. Good luck!
A tenant can be held liable for the cleaning and repairs that are "beyond normal wear and tear". If you can prove that the carpet and extra cleaning were the result of the tenant's occupancy then the court may allow you to charge the tenant for those items.
If the lease stated that smoking was not permitted, then you would have recourse for any damages you sustained, which would include cleaning or replacement of the carpet. If the lease says nothing about smoking (and most leases do not address smoking), then the tenant will claim that he was entitled to smoke in the rental property and the odor caused by smoking is merely "normal wear and tear"; he will probably win that argument. Before renting again, you may want to consider a "better" rental agreement. Incidentally, NONE of the rental forms in office supply stores or on the Internet (especially the ones that say they are good in all 50 states) DO NOT comply with Arizona law.
Consumers can use this platform to pose legal questions to real lawyers and receive free insights.
Participating legal professionals get the opportunity to speak directly with people who may need their services, as well as enhance their standing in the Lawyers.com community.