This is a potentially tricky issue, as it's unclear without reviewing your lease, as well as relevant case law, whether or not what they say is true. You certainly have claims that may well be viable to pursue in court if they're unwilling to cover the damage, but anytime you go into court it can become a risky proposition with no certainty of the outcome. It's unlikely, though not impossible, that such claims may be covered in Oregon's Residential Landlord Tenant Act, but you may well have a civil tort claim that might be worth pursuing. With small damages such as these, some attorney will consider taking the case on a contingency fee basis or a hybrid basis, as attorneys fees are potentially available to the winning party.
Answered on Dec 11th, 2012 at 12:42 PM