Tax records generally value a house on the assumption that it's in good condition. The actual value of the house would be reduced by any repairs which are necessary to restore the house to good condition. So if the place needs a roof, paint and a new furnace, get quotes on the roof, painting and furnace replacement.. This will give you evidence to argue that the house is worth less than $157,600. Now look at it from the trustee's point of view: the trustee doesn't want your house; she wants money. So it's a $157,600 house, that requires (say) $10,000 in repairs and has a $132,000 loan - that only gives her $157,600 minus $142,000 minus your $11,000 exemption or $4,600. She's not a real estate company, to sell the house she's got to pay a realtor (or auction company) say 7% of the sales price - that's over $10,000. So she'd get nothing. The reality is that trustees take over two types of house: 1. Houses with no mortgage and no exemption - since the whole price goes to the trustee, she's willing to go through the hassle of selling a $25,000 house, if it's free and clear. 2. Houses that have large percentage of equity - so a $100,000 with a $30,000 loan and a $20,000 exemption means 50% of the house is equity - she'll take it. But with the same $50,000 of equity - a $1,000,000 house with a $930,000 loan and $20,000 of exempt, isn't going to be worth her while - the realtor commission is much more on the more expensive house and often people will only buy a bankruptcy house if there is a discount. A 5% discount on a $100,000 house is only $5,000 and the trustee still gets $45,000. But a 5% discount on a $1 million dollar house wipes out her entire gain. Now if there's a $1 million house with $500,000 of equity, don't try to talk to trustee for a while - she'll be having orgasms....
Read More