Florida Criminal Defense Legal Questions

Want a good answer? Ask a thorough question starting with "Who, What, When, How, Will I or Do I".
Then, add details. This will help you get a quicker and better answer.
Question field is required
Explanation field is required
A valid US zip code is required Validating the Zip Code.
Question type field is required
Question type field is required
1
Ask a Question

2
Details

3
Submit
1
Ask a Question

2
Submit
Fullname is required
A valid email address is required.
Receive a follow-up from lawyers after your question is answered
A valid phone number is required
Select the best time for you to receive a follow-up call from a lawyer after your question is answered. (Required field)
to
Invalid Time

*Required fields

Question
Description
By submitting your question, you understand and agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy for use of the site. Do not include any personal information including name, email or other identifying details in your question or question details. An attorney-client relationship is not being established and you are not a prospective client of any attorney who responds to your question. No question, answer, or discussion of any kind facilitated on this site is confidential or legal advice. Questions answered are randomly selected based on general consumer interest and not all are addressed. Questions may display online and be archived by Martindale-Hubbell.
470 legal questions have been posted about criminal law by real users in Florida. Ask your question and dive into the knowledge of attorneys who handle your issue regularly. Similar topics to explore also include theft, weapons charges, and death penalty. All topics and other states can be accessed in the dropdowns below.
Florida Criminal Defense Questions & Legal Answers - Page 6
Do you have any Florida Criminal Defense questions page 6 and need some legal advice or guidance? Ask a Lawyer to get an answer or read through our 470 previously answered Florida Criminal Defense questions.

Recent Legal Answers

Yes, it will show up on your record.  However, depending on the disposition, it may not show up as a conviction.  For example, depending on where in Florida the charge was filed, the State Attorney may be willing to send the case to a diversion program.  If so, it is possible that if you successfully complete all conditions of the diversion program, the State would drop/dismiss/terminate the case.  The court records still would show you were accused and charged with the petty theft; but that the case was dismissed after you completed a diversion. program.   If you cannot get into a diversion program, you have a few other options:  (1) plead guilty or no contest, "straight up" to the court, without any plea bargain; the court then has discretion to give you any legal sentence; (2) work out a plea bargain with the State and enter a guilty or no contest plea to the charge; then the court will sentence you based on what was agreed to in the plea bargain; (3) fight the charge at trial.  If you win at trial, the case is done (although the arrest and case will still show up on your record); if you lose at trial, the court may impose any legal sentence. If, under any of the above options, the court, at the time of sentencing, agrees to withhold adjudication, it will still show up on your record.  But it will not be considered a "conviction" even though you will be sentenced and have a criminal record.  But if adjudication is withheld, then if you complete any applications (e.g., employment or housing applications) that ask if you have ever been convicted, you can answer "no."  (That's assuming you have no other prior convictions.). If the application asks if you have ever been convicted, regardless or whether adjudication was withheld, then you must answer "yes."  If your case was dropped after successfully completing a diversion program, the answer would be no.  Under all of the above options/dispositions the case/charge will show up on your record - but not necessarily as a conviction.  The only way to not have it show up on your record would be if the court sealed and/or expunged it.  That cannot be done in Florida if you have ever done that in the past or if you have ever been "convicted" of a prior criminal offense (regardless of the nature of the offense).   ... Read More
Yes, it will show up on your record.  However, depending on the disposition, it may not show up as a conviction.  For example, depending on... Read More

The person i work for said that i stole cash from jer house. Can i get arrested

Answered 5 years and 4 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
You should stop talking about it and when the police contact you do not speak to them and do not go voluntarily to the police station.   If not arrested you can leave and they do not have to give you permission. Keep your mouth shut and ask for a lawyer
You should stop talking about it and when the police contact you do not speak to them and do not go voluntarily to the police station.   If... Read More

Am I waiting on a court date for you son to be transferred

Answered 5 years and 4 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
The PDs Office wont do anything untilo he is brought there and they are appointed.   Transferring between counties is not occuring because of the pandemic.   Retain a lawyer in the county where the warrant came form and sometimes it can be lifted without him in court
The PDs Office wont do anything untilo he is brought there and they are appointed.   Transferring between counties is not occuring because of... Read More

Can you file for an appeal bond if you are back in county jail on a motion to withdraw plea?

Answered 5 years and 4 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
You should discuss this with his lawyer
You should discuss this with his lawyer

How can I get my vehicle back from property and evidence once my case has been dismissed?

Answered 5 years and 4 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
So ask them what paperwork is needed and get it and bring it to them
So ask them what paperwork is needed and get it and bring it to them
If you are going to trial, that means you have an attorney.   You should stop making public statements.   You should discuss all this with your lawyer
If you are going to trial, that means you have an attorney.   You should stop making public statements.   You should discuss all this... Read More

If my son is doing time in Alabama and has a hold for Florida charges will he be able to use his time there as time in Florida

Answered 5 years and 4 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
Probaby not. Most likely a warrant was not served on him. The hold is based on a detainer   He should consider the Interestate Agreement on Detainers   https://www.justice.gov/archives/jm/criminal-resource-manual-534-interstate-agreement-detainers
Probaby not. Most likely a warrant was not served on him. The hold is based on a detainer   He should consider the Interestate Agreement on... Read More
There is no question.
There is no question.

What shows up on a fingerprint background check?

Answered 5 years and 5 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
It all depends on where you are applying.   There are exemptions - federal, government, criminal justice agency, health, children.     By the way after a case is sealed for ten years you can get it expunged
It all depends on where you are applying.   There are exemptions - federal, government, criminal justice agency, health,... Read More

How long would it take to get a charge dropped or a plea to be given?

Answered 5 years and 6 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
He should have an attorney   Without knowing the extent of the perjury and what was said, as well as what damage was caysed by, makes it impossible to answer.   I f you find a lawyer who states that the lawyer can guarantee get away form the lawyer. No lawyer can guarantee. Tell the lawyer to put it in writing and the lawyer will not... Read More
He should have an attorney   Without knowing the extent of the perjury and what was said, as well as what damage was caysed by, makes it... Read More
lawyers like to answer questions accurately.   But when you write in run on sentence it is impossible
lawyers like to answer questions accurately.   But when you write in run on sentence it is impossible

Can i get this over turned

Answered 5 years and 6 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
three reasons I cannot answer   1) stop talking publicly or even privately except to your lawyer 2) you need a lawyer.  3) Lawyers want to answer questions accuratley. But when you write in a single run on sentence it is unclear,
three reasons I cannot answer   1) stop talking publicly or even privately except to your lawyer 2) you need a lawyer.  3) Lawyers want... Read More
Lawyers want to answer inquiries correctly.   However, I am unsure what you state because you have a run on sentence that runs 4 lines and several ands.   If you mean that .. is the end of sentence then use only one  per semtemce. More than one period looks like an ellipsis meaning something is missing... Read More
Lawyers want to answer inquiries correctly.   However, I am unsure what you state because you have a run on sentence that runs 4 lines and... Read More

If you have a attorney who is working on your case can you still make report against someone who made a false report on me ?

Answered 5 years and 6 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
No. I am dead and 6 feet under, but somehow I can respond   I do not understand but you should discuss this with your attorney as it may cause problems with his work and yours
No. I am dead and 6 feet under, but somehow I can respond   I do not understand but you should discuss this with your attorney as it may cause... Read More

what circutances would allow me to do probation or /and paid a fine charges of petty theft with priors

Answered 5 years and 6 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
Time to lawyer up...................................................................................................................
Time to lawyer up...................................................................................................................
The first thing I recommend doing is exercising your right to remain silent (meaning do not discuss what happened with anyone until after you meet with your attorney and get his/her advice).  The next thing I recommend is, if you do not have either a court-appointed attorney or private attorney, you need to get one as quickly as possible.  Your attorney should be able to obtain "Discovery" and assess whether you may have a case for filing for immunity under the "stand your ground" law -- or a self-defense issue.... Read More
The first thing I recommend doing is exercising your right to remain silent (meaning do not discuss what happened with anyone until after you meet... Read More
Since you were arrested and in jail, I assume you either bonded out immediately or went to a First Appearance Hearing (FAH).  If you went to a FAH, the judge should have asked whether you had, or wanted, an attorney.  Hopefully, you said "yes" to one of those questions.  If so, I assume you have either a court-appointed attorney or are in the process of retaining a private attorney to represent you.  That attorney should review the arrest and search procedure that was used in your case. There are too many factors that could influence what law enforcement had the right to do.  (So there is insufficient information, without seeing the various police reports, to know whether there was an illegal search -- or what defenses you may have.  Consequently, you need to set an appointment to discuss this with your attorney, who can request "Discovery" (which should include police reports).  In the meantime, remember you have the right to remain silent.  That means you do not have to talk about what happened with anyone.  So I would suggest that you not discuss the facts of this case with ANYONE (not even family members) until you meet and discuss it with your attorney.  Your attorney can then advise your further as to your right to remain silent and whether to exercise it further.      ... Read More
Since you were arrested and in jail, I assume you either bonded out immediately or went to a First Appearance Hearing (FAH).  If you went to a... Read More

Can a toxic and essential elements hair test by Doctor's Data, inc. be used as evidence and hold up in criminal court?

Answered 5 years and 6 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
Those test results do not prove you received any chemicals from a different source.   The chain of custody and accuracy of that method of testing is something which would have to be proven in court. Also you have to prove those chemicals caused negative effects.   No attorney would take your case under the limited proof you have alleged    ... Read More
Those test results do not prove you received any chemicals from a different source.   The chain of custody and accuracy of that method of... Read More
You need to retain a criminal defense attorney even if your suspicion is incorrect
You need to retain a criminal defense attorney even if your suspicion is incorrect
You are not an attorney. You cannot represent him. You need to retain counsel for him
You are not an attorney. You cannot represent him. You need to retain counsel for him

DId I commit assault and battery?

Answered 5 years and 8 months ago by attorney Diane Buerger   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
The short answer is you potentially could be charged with a criminal offense (if the person files a complaint or makes a police report) -- and you also could be sued civilly.  So I don't think this is something you want to be broadcasting (or bragging) about.
The short answer is you potentially could be charged with a criminal offense (if the person files a complaint or makes a police report) -- and you... Read More

What could be the sentencing?

Answered 5 years and 8 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
His attorney knows all about the facts of the case and his criminal history. The attorney should be consulted instead of a stranger        
His attorney knows all about the facts of the case and his criminal history. The attorney should be consulted instead of a... Read More

Arrest

Answered 5 years and 8 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
You cannot file anything. You are not a lawyer.   Time to hire a lawyer.   It is too serious a charge to experiment with
You cannot file anything. You are not a lawyer.   Time to hire a lawyer.   It is too serious a charge to experiment with

Negligent discharge of firearm

Answered 5 years and 8 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
A notice to appear in Florida is tanatamount to an arrest. You are lucky you were not formally arrested or you would have gone into jail and have to bond out
A notice to appear in Florida is tanatamount to an arrest. You are lucky you were not formally arrested or you would have gone into jail and have to... Read More

Can I own a gun if I have been charged with a felon but not convicted ? The case was dismissed all together.

Answered 5 years and 8 months ago by Mr. Gary Kollin (Unclaimed Profile)   |   1 Answer   |  Legal Topics: Criminal Defense
You have no conviction. Therefore you are not a felon
You have no conviction. Therefore you are not a felon